Why are there so many numbers?

Where are they?

In my math tutor practice I constantly answer questions. I usually get a lot of questions from my students. All kinds of math related questions. Some of them are very common, meaning, I get them all the time. For example, Calculus and Pre-Calculus students very often ask: “What is the domain?” “How do I find the domain of a function?” The vast majority of standardized test takers ask questions to the effect of “Why do I have to re-learn all this math stuff?” “When am I ever going to use it?” Sometimes I get questions that make me laugh, like: “How can you stand so much math? My head hurts!” and “Do you also have a real job? Or, is this all you do?”

Recently a student asked me a couple questions I found just fascinating. We were going over some algebra rules. I started giving her some numerical examples to illustrate one of the rules. All of a sudden my student asked: “Why are there so many numbers? Where are they?” These are great questions! They get to the root of the concept of number. Just think about these questions for a moment. “Where are they?” Where are the numbers? It is almost like asking: “Where do numbers come from?” or even “How can I believe numbers really exist? Can I see them?” It is clear numbers are not physical objects but we use them to count physical objects all the time. You believe in the existence of something concrete, like cars, because you can easily see them (often in big numbers), but what about numbers themselves? Do we ever get to see a number? What we usually call numbers, like street addresses, or numbers in license plates, or ID cards, or page numbers in a book, all those are not actually numbers but numerals, the symbols we use to represent numbers. Numbers are in our mind. They are concepts, ideas, thoughts, more than things. My answer to these questions was along the following lines:

Numbers are everywhere. We do not see the numbers but we put numbers on the things we see. Numbers show up as soon as you are able to tell differences and similarities. Think about counting the chairs in this coffee shop, for example. When you count the chairs you do not count the tables, or the bookcases, only the chairs. So you count them because they are equal, they are all chairs. However, you do not keep pointing your finger at the same chair while going 1, 2, 3,.. You count that chair and immediately you go on to the next chair for the next number. So you count them with different numbers because they are all different chairs. What makes counting possible is our ability to identify a set of objects that are all equal, in a sense, yet different, in another sense. So we can “see” numbers when we look at the stars, at the grains of sand in a beach, or the cars in a highway, and so on. As long as our mind sees the world in terms of “equal” and “different,” numbers will be there, everywhere.

Helping Students Find Their Own Motivation To Learn

What is in it for the student, from the student's own perspective?

It is important for students to understand teachers are helping them to figure out what they want to do in life, and are helping them achieve those goals. It is not enough for teachers to give students examples of what students do not want to do in life. Teachers want to inspire students to learn; to give them an appreciation for knowledge; to show them how to put value into knowledge, and how to extract value from it. For working adults is easier to see how, in this technological world of ours, meaningful numerical patterns come from everyday life. Numerical patterns coming at us directly from real life make us think about reality in terms of numbers. The more comfortable we are with numbers, and with handling them, the better we can express the ideas suggested to us by those numerical patterns. Sooner or later, in one form or another, we realize the math we currently know is somehow inadequate to analyze the data we want to understand. Even for students who have always been good at math, there may come a point where their homework problems baffle them. This may be because such students tend to enroll in AP classes at an early age. By the time they are high school seniors, they are already covering material some science majors only get to learn about in their college sophomore year. Therefore, it is important for students to create good study habits since early in life. Study is not only preparation for work but study in and of itself can be an awful lot of work. Given that study takes time, energy, and other resources, it is important for students to be able to associate it with experiences of achievement, and empowerment. Success means different things for different people; it even means different things for the same person at different points in their life. Often students question themselves: "Is this effort worthwhile?" Some sort of confirmation is needed about it. The discipline of doing homework with a good degree of concentration, regardless of whether or not we like a particular subject that much, pays off when, thanks to that consistent effort, we are able to see the things that interest us in a new light. For many, it may mean just getting past a particular requirement, thereby clearing their horizon from a bulky obstacle. Clearing out such requirements can give students an improved sense of self-esteem, and a renewed confidence in themselves. Another important factor may be taking our time to learn things thoroughly, to make the subject ours, to make sure we really understand it, because then we know what to do at any given point, instead of feeling like randomly throwing darts in the dark, and hoping to achieve some result by chance. There are many factors involved in learning. Each student builds their own learning strategy, according to what they determine is best for them. Teachers can only hope to influence in some measure such decision making process on the student's part. Students constantly make these decisions on their own, multiple times a day, choosing the way they study, selecting what gives them the best possible outcomes in their own world, according to everything they consider important - not necessarily what other people consider important for them. For some students it is more important to find ways of having fun while learning. Others predominantly focus on their long term goals (passing exams with a good enough score) without almost ever giving themselves the chance to consider their learning experience from any perspective other than their test results. In summary, it is important for students to find educators who can provide them not only with facts but also with motivation enough for grasping those facts, and applying them.

Ubiquitous Numbers

One and Zero are always everywhere

The more you tutor math, the more skilled you become in finding good, clear ways to explain all types of math concepts to students. However, some concepts are more elusive than others. The difficulty of grasping a concept depends not only on the concept itself but also on the student who is assimilating it. One person, for example, can easily understand polynomial multiplication, and struggle with percentages, while someone else can find percentages very easy but have trouble with polynomials. There are also some concepts or topics that seem to be hard for a significant majority of students, like word problems for instance.
Substitution is a very powerful problem-solving technique, and it is widely used in a variety of situations. Students who find substitution easy have a clear advantage over students who have trouble understanding it. Substitution comes up in many different ways, some more complex than others. Some students understand the more basic forms of substitution but have problems applying the same techniques when dealing with more complex expressions. In fact, a very consistent general trend is the host of negative reactions students tend to show in varying degrees when facing bigger, longer, more complicated expressions. The more complex the expression, the more likely that students will get confused, or feel overwhelmed by it.
There is a particular way of using substitution to which most students react with a strong resistance: It involves transforming a given expression into another one that is equivalent in value but looks more complicated. This is done with the ultimate goal of simplifying the expression but it starts out by complicating it a little more. It is like climbing up a hill to find a way down the mountain.
The most common way of using this technique is by introducing a representation of the numbers Zero or One into the given expression.
Zero and One are very special numbers. They implicitly are everywhere in any given algebraic expression, even when we do not see them written out.
Zero is called the additive identity because zero plus any number is that same number ( x + 0 = x ).
One is called the multiplicative identity because one times any number equals that same number ( x∙1 = x ).
These two properties make Zero and One algebraically omnipresent in an implicit way.
Further, we have the following properties:
A number subtracted from itself equals zero ( x – x = 0 ).
A number different from zero, when divided by itself gives us one as the result ( x/x = 1 ).
These last two properties give Zero and One an infinite number of representations (“disguises” if you will) to show up in a formula. So, not only are Zero and One ubiquitous, they can come in a dizzying multiplicity of seemingly different forms.
The above properties of Zero and One, and their consequences, make them extremely useful in solving equations, and in manipulating algebraic expressions in general.
However, as I mentioned before, many students present a strong resistance to the idea of making an expression more complicated to be able to reduce it later. This is partly because they do not see the point of multiplying a number times one, or adding zero to it; partly because doing so seems to increase the problem in size and complexity; partly because they feel we are working backwards into some uncalled-for calculation, and finally because they believe they would not know what particular form of Zero or One they are supposed to introduce into the expression if they were doing the problem on their own.
Sometimes, when working with a student on a given problem, it is very easy for me to see a path to the solution using these types of techniques but I have learned to make sure the student does not feel like I was expecting him or her to be able to solve the problem in the same way. I only use these techniques when the student is completely stuck in the problem, not making any progress at all. When they see one possible solution, it gives them some perspective on the different factors playing a role in the problem. After showing them one possible solution method, if they do not feel comfortable that they would be able to successfully use the same method on their own, we focus on finding an alternate method that works better for them.

The Square of a Sum

An arithmetic and geometric approach to Algebra

A very common mistake test takers make when they have been out of school for a while is that they automatically try to expand the square of a sum as if it was the same as the plain sum of the squares of the individual terms. For example, sometimes some students, when presented with say, (x + 5)², they wrongly expand it as x² + 25, leaving out the middle term 10x.
They forget they have to use the foil method to multiply the given sum times itself. Since typographically the sum of the squares looks like something that could equal the square of the sum, they guess they can expand the square that way, as if it was a real math rule, and then they get the problem wrong.
I try to preemptively address the possibility of this mistake, because both sums of squares and squares of sums show up a lot in the math section of standardized tests. For a long time I have used a drawing, with two little squares and two congruent rectangles filling up a larger square, to show the geometric interpretation (in terms of area) for the algebraic formula (a + b)² = a² + 2ab + b². I emphasize the middle term, 2ab, in this expansion, and I point to the corresponding two rectangles in the drawing.
The above approach is useful but many students forget the formula when it comes to actually applying it. Most do not realize it is a universal pattern where to plug any other expressions in.
So, lately I have been experimenting with a slightly different approach: I present two or three numerical examples first, before drawing the squares and rectangles. I ask the student to choose two numbers, and then I guide them through a sequence of calculations that allows them to actually compute and see the numerical difference between the square of the sum, and the sum of the squares. Then I ask them to multiply the original numbers, then to double this product. By asking all the questions in the right order, I have gotten comments from them like: “Wow!” or “How weird!” or “That is so funny!” or “This is very interesting!” or “Does it always work like that?” or “How can that be?” or “What is going on?” or “I’m sure there is a pattern here!” Then I draw the squares and rectangles with all the numbers in their proper places. So, creating the perception of a “mystery” with the numbers, and then explaining it away with the picture seems to work well. It makes sense for the students. They usually say: “Oh, right! Now I get it.”

Welcome to Number City!

Find your way around. Don’t get lost.

Sometimes students ask me: “How long is going to take for me to pass this test?”
To which I reply: “It all depends on how fast you get to the performance level you need for the score you want.”
The key phrase here is “performance level,” which the tests are supposed to measure.
Sometimes I have to be almost brutally honest by saying: “Look, realistically, as long as you keep hesitating for more than three seconds to come up with the result of a single-digit multiplication, there is no chance you are going to solve a whole problem in less than two minutes. You want to have all those little things down to less than a couple seconds, with no hesitation whatsoever. You have to let go of all those thoughts about not being good at math, or not liking math. If you really want to pass this test, you need to learn how to handle fractions, and all these other things you always hated and have never completely understood so far.”
There is an interesting metaphor I find useful to help students start distancing themselves from their math phobias. I say:
“Think of it this way: Imagine Math is a city you used to visit when you were a child, a city you never liked because you always got lost, or maybe even someone stole your money, or you always got sick when you were there, or something bad like that. I acknowledge it’s only natural for you to harbor bad feelings about that city. Now, because you want to pass this test, it is like now you have to move to that city and live there for a few months. Not only that but, to finally get out of it, you need to work three jobs while you are there, and you need to excel at all of them. You are going to deliver packages during the day, deliver pizzas at night, and drive a taxi cab on the weekends. Do you think you can allow yourself the luxury of being lost again? Are you going to stand there all confused for hours about how to cross the street, or about what avenue takes you downtown? To really do well in those three jobs you want to know all the landmarks, the big buildings, the highways, street names, bus routes, trolley stops, shopping malls, different neighborhoods, and the like, right? So, it’s just like that in math, too. Welcome to Number City. That is why I recommend you to memorize by heart the times tables, square numbers, primes, powers of two, odds, evens, integers, and things like that, so you can easily find your way around and move from place to place as fast as you can without getting lost again. Number sets like “squares” or “primes” are like avenues. Each individual number is like a franchise brand name, with multiple locations around the city. Algebraic operation rules are ways to get fast from place A to place B, like taking the subway or the highway or something like that. You want to set aside your old fears and phobias for a while, and apply yourself to the task of getting to know your way around this city. Then you will pass your test and you will be able to move out and move on with your life. That is what’s needed.”
I find the above analogy helps some students to kind of materialize their math fears and phobias into something external, and objective. They know what is like to familiarize oneself with a new city, so this is a task that looks familiar, doable, and makes sense for them. So they can stop the negative workout on their self-esteem, and focus instead on these concrete and essential memorization steps.

Factored Integers

A memorization exercise

Last week I added a new page to my tutoring web site. The new page’s title is “Factored Integers.” It is a reference page listing about 200 positive integers, completely factored out as products of smaller numbers, including their prime factorization.
The purpose of such a list is for some standardized test takers to do a memorization exercise. The idea is for the student to copy this list, and to write by hand a portion of it every day, anywhere from 20 to 50 numbers a day.
Just writing down the numbers and their factorizations has a cumulative effect in the student’s memory, as long as they do the exercise every day. Standardized test have many problems that can be solved much faster by factoring numbers out than by doing long multiplications and divisions.
Time is the most precious resource in a timed test, so the goal is for the student to have readily available, fresh in their memory, these factorizations, instead of wasting time thinking about what could be a possible factorization, or even worse, going down the path of long multiplications and divisions, because these operations become very time consuming, and prone to errors when the numbers involved are large.
So the best way to solve these problems is by factoring all numbers as much as possible, and simplifying all expressions as much as possible by canceling out any common factors that can be canceled out before getting into any multiplication.
So the value of the memorization exercise resides in the increased awareness of factors the student develops a little bit each day by writing and re-writing the list of factorizations.
The goal is for the student to start thinking about a number’s factors as soon as they see the number in the problem; naturally, automatically, by default, without even thinking about it. See a number, boom! Factor it. The less time you spend on this process at test time, the better. So the time spent at home writing and re-writing the list will pay off on test day.